Changing to Gmail|Everything Else Forum|Forums: Ask the Geeks!|GeeksOnTour.COM

Please ask your questions here (not in email) – we promise to respond here, no such promise with email. This is a benefit of membership. Here’s info  on how to post to this Q&A Forum. If you need more help, you can book a 30 minute one-on-one Zoom meeting using our Office Hours feature.

You must be logged in as a Premium Member to Ask the Geeks a question. All are welcome to freely browse the Forums.

Lost password?
Advanced Search
Forum Scope


Forum Options

Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters
Changing to Gmail
December 12, 2019
5:02 pm
Robert Stovall
Forum Posts: 18
Member Since:
November 10, 2018
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

More than 20 years ago we had but one choice for ISP, Comcast. We foolishly elected to use Comcast for our email. Over time we have become “absorbed” by Comcast (think Star Trek’s Borg) with services including not only Internet but also cable TV & phone. The monthly bills have become too much & we are ready to abandon Comcast & go with the new kid on the block, Fios (they have laid fiber optic along our street), for Internet connectivity only. TV channels will be accessed via various streaming services like Hulu. (Our daughter & son-in-law have elected this & reaped considerable savings & connection speeds).

The problem is our long-ago foolish choice establishing email identities as [XXX] It’s daunting enough to notify familiar correspondents like our friends/associates of new Gmail addresses, but REALLY terrifying to imagine all other connections we will inevitably forget & the consequences of missing that important once-a-year notification from [Y] or that friend we’ve not corresponded with in 3 years.

My research into switching to Gmail at this point suggests:

  1. Comcast will continue to allow use of their email server & identity as long as we login to their website & email once every 9 months (subject to our memory lapses & Comcast’s not changing their rules)
  2. Comcast will “forward” email to another address if we ask (again subject to Comcast not changing their rules, & I suspect they will not be sympathetic to former customers if there is a problem)

I CAN fathom a change to Gmail by notifying correspondents using the tools above & my limited memory/diligence. A major issue, however, will be keeping/transferring previous emails. I don’t think Comcast maintains a substantial history, but my email client (Mozilla’s Thunderbird) does on my WIN10 desktop (which history I access frequently for both my personal & consulting business needs). Adding to the complication – my wife uses Apple’s email client.

  • Do you have suggestions to add to the two above?
  • Is there a way to use our client email address lists to facilitate notification of our new Gmail addresses?
  • How will I transfer my email history to Gmail?


December 12, 2019
10:05 pm
Forum Posts: 3401
Member Since:
July 2, 2010
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

First of all, don’t beat yourself up about choosing email address. It was a perfectly reasonable choice 20 years ago. 

Today – I agree, an address is a good choice. But, if you already have a custom domain like – you may want to use that for your email address. Gmail can still be your inbox. See this article of mine for more detail on that.

Gmail’s inbox is surprisingly good at importing email and contacts from other systems. You should be able to use the Account options (Gear icon) and Settings, Accounts and Import, Import mail and contacts – to get the current content of your comcast account as well as that which is stored in Thunderbird as well. 

You’re still looking at quite a process for both you and your wife to get your emails changed. That’s great that Comcast will let you use their email – but still you want to embark on a process that will allow you to close that account eventually. You should be able to set up an auto-responder on your account that sends a reply to every incoming email saying that your address has changed. 

I recommend writing up a checklist and keeping it somewhere that you will always have it (Google keep or Google Docs) so you have a written plan of the steps you’re going to take and when each one gets done.

For an overall plan, I agree with everything in this Lifehacker article:  How to Change Your Email Address Without Screwing Everything Up

Hope that helps

Forum Timezone: America/New_York
Most Users Ever Online: 722
Currently Online:
Guest(s) 6
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
Roxie Marston: 118
Bob Brown: 96
James: 94
guppy1: 83
LuVerne Underhill: 79
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 402
Members: 1328
Moderators: 1
Admins: 3
Forum Stats:
Groups: 3
Forums: 19
Topics: 2470
Posts: 8140
Newest Members:, Devon G, Micekteers, Judy Claypool, Dottie
Moderators: Jim: 0
Administrators: JimAdmin: 456, MrsGeek: 3401, David Carr: 1